Following the new that the UK has agreed a free trade deal with New Zealand, CLA Cymru is questioning the benefit of the deal for Welsh farmers.
The deal was struck between Prime Minister Boris Johnson and New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern - following 16 months of talks by the UK Department for International Trade negotiators. UK-New Zealand trade was worth £2.3 billion last year and is expected to grow under the deal. It’s hoped the deal will remove barriers to trade and make it easier for smaller businesses to break into the New Zealand market.
CLA Deputy President Mark Tufnell, who manages farm land in Wales says, “Instinctively, we support free trade, but by definition there has to be something in it for both sides. We see the opportunity for New Zealand farmers in this deal, but we aren’t so sure what the opportunity is for those of us in the UK.
“Over time, New Zealand will be able to sell even larger quantities of meat and dairy produce into the UK, often produced much more cheaply than we can do ourselves. This risks undercutting UK farmers and putting a question-mark over the viability of their businesses.
Government is leaving the industry in the dark about what this deal really means for agriculture, setting a worrying precedent for other Free Trade Agreements we may strike with other major food exporters – many of which have far lower animal welfare and environmental standards than we do. Government promised that suitable checks and balances would be put in place to ensure we would not be undercut in this way. So far, they have failed to materialise.
“We now need a serious conversation with government at both a devolved and UK-level, particularly about the formation of the Trade & Agriculture Commission, and a response to its predecessor’s report. If ministers expect us to compete on the global stage, they need to help us to do so, and we need further support from trade envoys and better labelling to inform consumer choice.”