Infrastructure reform and the implications for landowners
As changes to compulsory purchase and energy legislation take shape, we look at where landowner protections could be strengthened and where they risk being weakened
Two key developments were announced this month which could bring significant changes to infrastructure law and have important implications for landowners. In this blog, we discuss those changes and what they mean for rural land managers and their agents.
‘Reform of the Crichel Down Rules’ Consultation
For those unfamiliar, the Crichel Down Rules are non-statutory binding government guidance about land acquired by many public bodies using, or under threat of, compulsory purchase powers. The rules require, with lots of caveats, that if that land is surplus to the public body’s needs it must be offered to its former owner before it can be disposed of in any other way.
This consultation proposes a number of technical changes which mainly reduce the circumstances in which the rules apply.
Perhaps the most striking is that a long lease will no longer count as a “disposal” under the rules. Therefore, acquirers could lease surplus land out for periods of 999 years plus without needing to offer the land back to its former owner. This is particularly striking, as the 1954 political scandal which led to the rules creation saw land transferred between government departments and then leased out to a third party. This situation would not have triggered the rules as proposed by this consultation.
Also it will be up to the disposing body, without ministerial oversight, to decide whether there is an exception to the rules in a given case. As the consultation stands, the only way to challenge this would be a prohibitively expensive judicial review.
One of these exceptions will be that areas of land which the acquiring authority thinks would cost them more to dispose of than the land’s value will not be subject to the rules.
Another existing exception is that the rules do not apply where there has been a “material change” to the land which renders unsuitable for its former purpose. The consultation seeks change this in two ways. Firstly, it will make clear that a change to any part of the land amounts to a material change to all of it. Secondly, it will include linear infrastructure such as pipes or electricity poles as a material change. This means that if compulsory purchase powers were used on a 1,000-acre farm and 5m of electricity line went over one field corner, the rules would no longer apply.
Time limits will be introduced on when the rules may take effect. The rules will no longer apply to disposals of agricultural land after 25 years, or non-agricultural land after 15 years.
The rules will also no longer apply where land is transferred between public bodies where it is needed by one department for a statutory purpose, even if the transferee does not have compulsory purchase powers.
There is a small silver lining in that the rules will explicitly apply to a wider range of public bodies than they did previously, such as councils.
The CLA agrees with the government that the rules are complicated and time consuming to use. However, the solution to this is not to further expand the rat’s nest of exceptions and complexities to which they are already subject. It is instead to build a new set of modern fully statutory rules that apply to all acquirers, including the private sector, with a logical form and a clear and accessible means of challenge when they are not correctly applied. It is disappointing that the government has taken an opposite view, merely weakening the protections offered without simplifying the system in which they exist.
The Energy Independence Bill (EIB)
With 186 sections and 10 schedules across its 326 pages, this is a highly imposing piece of draft legislation. However, most of its provisions relate to the regulation of the energy sector rather than matters which directly affect farmers and landowners.
There are however a few points we have noticed and wish to draw to our members’ attention.
Firstly, the EIB offers a mixed bag of changes to the “necessary wayleave” process under which electricity companies can access land to keep and maintain poles and pylons. On one hand, compensation provisions for landowners will become stronger when access is taken for maintenance work, and lopping trees near to power lines will no longer be the landowner’s responsibility. On the other hand, there will be new rights of access for high-voltage operators (who could not previously use the powers) and over third party land for the sake of access. Higher-voltage operators will, however, be subject to a longer notice period than existing users. There will be new circumstances where operators can demand to have a new “wayleave” agreement imposed for existing lines.
Perhaps the most important of these changes, however, is a focus on alternative dispute resolution for disputes about payments. This is a very positive step which should reduce litigation and so expense for both members and operators. It is important, however, that the legislation is drafted to ensure it really does have its intended effect.
Secondly, those operating electric vehicle charging points or supplying others from renewables (potentially such as tenants) may be subject to new regulation. We do not know what form this regulation may take. The bill would simply enable it to exist. Estates who operate this kind of infrastructure should be aware that change may be coming – we will keep you updated as we learn more.
Finally, the bill lays out the groundwork for an expansion of “community” energy projects – renewables projects designed to supply a specific group of people rather than the wider grid. This is tentatively positive as an opportunity for members to work with those around them on projects which could be beneficial to all. We will continue to observe as the situation develops.
In conclusion
The infrastructure landscape continues to change, but steadily. It is striking to contrast the acquirer-focused policy of the Ministry of Communities, Housing and Local Government, which wrote the Crichel Down consultation, to the more measured approach of the Department of Energy Security and Net Zero, which drafted the EIB. The EIB suggests a government which knows an efficient rollout of infrastructure requires a clear and enforceable set of rules upon both parties. This must mean simple and easily accessible redress to prevent low level disputes and questionable conduct from escalating to the senior courts. We will continue to work with government to create such a system.