Defra must not ignore CAP advice, say CLA and NFU
The Government must listen to warnings that it could put British farmers at a competitive disadvantage if exposed to higher rates of modulation than other EU farmers, CLA President Harry Cotterell and NFU President Peter Kendall have said.
The two presidents were speaking following the publication of the House of Commons Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Efra) Committee's findings of its inquiry into the European Commission proposals to green the CAP.
Mr Cotterell said: "The findings of this inquiry lay down a number of very useful markers for Defra as it negotiates on behalf of British farmers in Brussels. We agree with the Efra committee that the competitiveness of UK farmers will be significantly impacted by the Commission's greening plans if they were to go ahead as are currently proposed. We also agree that Defra must not seek to gold plate any greening measures by applying higher conditions on farmers in this country."
The Efra report states that "the competitiveness of UK farmers will be reduced if they are exposed to higher modulation rates than their competitors" and recommends that "Defra should not set modulation rates higher than other member states that receive similar single farm payment rates".
"The UK is the only member state to use voluntary modulation and it is incredibly frustrating when we hear that Defra negotiators are arguing for ways to increase the amount of money that can be transferred from the direct payments envelope purely on a national basis," said Mr Kendall.
"We hope that Defra takes heed of this finding and rather than expending negotiating capital arguing for the right to cut payments at the national level, that instead it focuses attention on securing a better allocation of rural development money from Brussels. To do otherwise certainly would not be fair to farmers."
Read the Efra Select Committee report on Greening the Common Agricultural Policy.
CLA Member Login
Christopher Price is the Director Policy and Advice at the CLA. He has overall responsibility for managing all the CLA's national policy and advisory work. He makes sure that the organisation's policy work is focused on what matters most, and that members' queries are dealt with accurately and efficiently. A planning and environmental lawyer by background, he joined the CLA as public law adviser in 2002. He became Chief Legal Advisor in 2007 and took up his current post a year later. Before coming to the CLA Christopher worked in local government for a number of different authorities.
The CLA Game Fair 2013
More articles and documents
Industry coalition calls for fair deal on CAP
[27 February 2013]
GN05-12 Permanent Pasture/Grassland Requirements - the current rules under the Single Payment Scheme (SPS) and proposed permanent grassland requirements under the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) reform
[5 March 2012]
Impact Assessment on the CAP towards 2020 proposals
[Consultation response archive]
[16 February 2011]
© 2013 Country Land and Business Association Limited (CLA). All rights reserved. No part of this website may be reproduced or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, or stored in any retrieval system of any nature without prior written permission of the copyright holder except as expressly permitted by law.
No responsibility for loss occasioned to any person acting or refraining from action in reliance on or as a result of the material included in or omitted in this website can be or is accepted by the author(s), the CLA or its officers or trustees or employees or any other persons.
The Advisory Services are made available to members on the basis that members' rights to compensation and the liability (if any) of CLA and its officers and/or its staff advisers, are restricted in the following ways. In the event of any advice given by any CLA staff adviser being given negligently or otherwise being incorrect no liability whatsoever is accepted by the CLA or its officers or by its staff advisers concerned
(a) towards any person who is not the current CLA member to whom the advice was directly given,
(b) to any person in the respect of consequential loss or loss of profits, or
(c) to any person for any sum exceeding £50,000 in respect of any one enquiry (whether made or responded to orally or in writing and whether dealt with at one time or over a period of time).
Any person making use of the Advisory Services accepts such restrictions. Members should refer to appropriate professional advisers in private practice before taking any particular course of action potentially or actually involving any substantial amounts of money.
Please note that whilst the advisers are able to advise on a wide range of subjects relating to land ownership, they cannot act in place of a member's own solicitor, accountant, surveyor and tax specialist by, for example, drafting documents or corresponding on their behalf and may be precluded, by the rules of their own professions, from advising one CLA member against another CLA member in the case of conflict.
Solicitors Indemnity Fund . Solicitors in the CLA Legal Team are not covered by the Solicitors Indemnity Fund in relation to professional negligence in relation to any advice given by them.
Please note that from time to time telephone calls maybe recorded for training purposes.